3 Myths About Mac OS X [Updated!]

Years of switch ads and John Hodgman awesomeness have finally gotten to me. I bought a 15″ MacBook Pro. I’m living the iLife. It’s my first real Apple experience since the Apple IIe, overall I’m pretty impressed, though I have this sinking feeling that I’m not using OS X to it’s fullest potential.

That said, there are a few major myths about the operating system that need to be busted.

1. It’s easier to use
For a long time, Macs (even before OS X) had the unfortunate distinction as the “dummy” computer, good for old people and computer illiterates. Because of this sterotype, I had assumed the the user-interface was somehow inherently easier to use. This is absoultely untrue.
Some things are a little easier. Installing apps is a little easier, sometimes, depending on the installer. Systems preferences is a laid out a little better than the Windows control panels, especially Vista’s. Apps integrate with the OS a little better. Spotlight is pretty awesome. But in general, things are just different, no better or worse than Windows.

A number of important apps/features are actually harder to use:

  • cmd vs ctrl: The OS X equivalent of the control key – in windows (and gnome for that matter) – is command. ctrl+z in windows, translates to cmd+z in osx. The issue here is keyboard layout. The cmd key is located right next to the spacebar. This makes any shift+cmd combination extremely difficult to pull off.
  • Finder Sucks!: Finder is just not a very good way to manipulate files. The main problem is the lack of an “up” button to navigate to the parent directory. Finder has a back button – “back” isn’t always “up.” Finder also has a dropdown which lists all the directories in the path, while this is a more efficient way to go navigate “up” 2 directories or more, it’s less efficient when you want to navigate up 1 directory – 2 clicks to use the dropdown vs. 1 click to use an “up” button.
    Another issue is the accordion directory interface you get in list view – 1 click opens the directory in the current view, 2 clicks opens the directory as your current view.
    The list view itself is also broken. There is no way to organize the list view to match the default windows list view. I.E. Directories at the top, files below, in alphabetical order.
    Don’t even get me started on the “save file” interface.
  • Menu Bar: While I think the top of the screen is actually the correct location for things like the clock and other indicators, the menu bar paradigm does not work well with multiple displays. When I open an app on my secondary display I have to go back to the primary display everytime I want to use the app’s menus. Really does not make any sense.
  • Dock: It’s kind of useless.
  • Alert Boxes: Application alerts (eg. “Are you sure you want to exit”) appear at the top of the app window, as opposed to the center of the screen. This is another minor UI mistake, imho.

2. Security features are not annoying
OS X warns me the first I open a file or run an app I’ve downloaded off the internet (even if i actually downloaded the file in an archive). Enough said.

3. It doesn’t crash
In a week of use I’ve had 2 or 3 (stable) apps crash, the OS froze and needed to be powercycled once. This is not a good start.

UPDATE!:

Setupmac.com has a solution to my issue with the up button.
First, the keyboard shortcut ⌘↑ goes to the “enclosing folder.” I think this alone solves my problem!!
Second, they also have a patch to add an up button to the finder toolbar.
Link

  • I’ll need to follow up on this comment because I have tons of suggestions (I just went through this a few months ago) but I’m @ work.
    Anyway, a quick suggestion for 1A is to reverse the control and command keys. It’ll confuse the crap out of other Mac users, but you’ll be able to use your ingrained Windows shortcuts AND you won’t have to go through finger aerobics to copy and paste.

    The dock is kind of a combination of the task bar and quick launch. Very Windows 7. Mehhhh.

  • Re: keyboard. I’ve gotten used to it enough that I think I would just confuse myself again.

    Re: Dock. I don’t know if I actually hate it, just seems very meh.

  • Re: keyboard. I’ve gotten used to it enough that I think I would just confuse myself again.

    Re: Dock. I don’t know if I actually hate it, just seems very meh.

  • Re: keyboard. I’ve gotten used to it enough that I think I would just confuse myself again.

    Re: Dock. I don’t know if I actually hate it, just seems very meh.

  • Genifer

    I think I’ve only crashed mine twice so far, and I’ll have had it a year next month, so that makes me happy. Right now this window is on the Macbook screen but the main screen is my external monitor, so it’s all confusing. Still. Yeah. Dumb.

    Still, looking back, it was either a laptop I didn’t really want with XP, a bit nicer laptop but with Vista, or a Macbook? I’m still super happy with my choice.

  • Genifer

    I think I’ve only crashed mine twice so far, and I’ll have had it a year next month, so that makes me happy. Right now this window is on the Macbook screen but the main screen is my external monitor, so it’s all confusing. Still. Yeah. Dumb.

    Still, looking back, it was either a laptop I didn’t really want with XP, a bit nicer laptop but with Vista, or a Macbook? I’m still super happy with my choice.

  • Genifer

    I think I’ve only crashed mine twice so far, and I’ll have had it a year next month, so that makes me happy. Right now this window is on the Macbook screen but the main screen is my external monitor, so it’s all confusing. Still. Yeah. Dumb.

    Still, looking back, it was either a laptop I didn’t really want with XP, a bit nicer laptop but with Vista, or a Macbook? I’m still super happy with my choice.

  • You probably already know about this, but the best thing you can do to make your mac experience infinitely better is to install Quicksilver (http://www.blacktree.com/). It’s like a more awesome spotlight, with the functionality that finder should have, and the dock tries to.

  • You probably already know about this, but the best thing you can do to make your mac experience infinitely better is to install Quicksilver (http://www.blacktree.com/). It’s like a more awesome spotlight, with the functionality that finder should have, and the dock tries to.

  • You probably already know about this, but the best thing you can do to make your mac experience infinitely better is to install Quicksilver (http://www.blacktree.com/). It’s like a more awesome spotlight, with the functionality that finder should have, and the dock tries to.

  • RussTM

    I second @greg2point0 .

    Even if you just use it as a basic launcher it is awesome. Faster than waiting for the spotlight list to populate.

    The clip board manager is useful.

    Lots of configuration available, but not necessary for it to be useful.

    Apparently the author is now working on Google’s next launcher.

  • RussTM

    I second @greg2point0 .

    Even if you just use it as a basic launcher it is awesome. Faster than waiting for the spotlight list to populate.

    The clip board manager is useful.

    Lots of configuration available, but not necessary for it to be useful.

    Apparently the author is now working on Google’s next launcher.

  • RussTM

    I second @greg2point0 .

    Even if you just use it as a basic launcher it is awesome. Faster than waiting for the spotlight list to populate.

    The clip board manager is useful.

    Lots of configuration available, but not necessary for it to be useful.

    Apparently the author is now working on Google’s next launcher.

  • @RussTM yes, icholas Jitkoff (Quicksilver developer) now works for Google, and has created the Google Quick Search Box (http://googlemac.blogspot.com/2009/01/search-without-effort-quick-search-box.html) but after trying it out for a few days I’ve gone back to Quicksilver.

  • @RussTM yes, icholas Jitkoff (Quicksilver developer) now works for Google, and has created the Google Quick Search Box (http://googlemac.blogspot.com/2009/01/search-without-effort-quick-search-box.html) but after trying it out for a few days I’ve gone back to Quicksilver.

  • @RussTM yes, icholas Jitkoff (Quicksilver developer) now works for Google, and has created the Google Quick Search Box (http://googlemac.blogspot.com/2009/01/search-without-effort-quick-search-box.html) but after trying it out for a few days I’ve gone back to Quicksilver.

  • I'll need to follow up on this comment because I have tons of suggestions (I just went through this a few months ago) but I'm @ work.
    Anyway, a quick suggestion for 1A is to reverse the control and command keys. It'll confuse the crap out of other Mac users, but you'll be able to use your ingrained Windows shortcuts AND you won't have to go through finger aerobics to copy and paste.

    The dock is kind of a combination of the task bar and quick launch. Very Windows 7. Mehhhh.